With its judgment 7B_544/2026 of 13 October 2026, the Swiss Federal Supreme Court clarified that in-house counsel cannot invoke legal professional privilege in criminal or administrative criminal proceedings. The “in-house privilege” introduced in 2025 under Article 167a of the Swiss Civil Procedure Code (CPC) applies exclusively to civil proceedings and cannot be extended to criminal proceedings.
Facts of the Case: A Bank, Two Data Carriers, and an Application for Sealing
The Federal Department of Finance (FDF) is conducting administrative criminal proceedings against the as yet unidentified individuals responsible at a bank. The allegation concerns a possible violation of the reporting obligations under Article 37 of the Anti-Money Laundering Act (AMLA). By way of an information and production order dated 22 May 2025, the FDF requested numerous documents.
The bank produced the documents on two password-protected data carriers. It requested that the second data carrier be sealed. On 16 March 2026, the Appeals Chamber of the Federal Criminal Court granted the FDF’s request for unsealing. The bank subsequently appealed to the Federal Supreme Court, seeking the exclusion of ten specific documents, including a Staff Manual. It relied on two arguments:
- Protection of trade secrets; and
- Legal professional privilege of its in-house lawyers.
Federal Supreme Court’s Decision: Unsealing Allowed, In-House Privilege Rejected
The Federal Supreme Court dismissed the appeal in its entirety.
Trade Secrets
The Court held that it is insufficient merely to assert the existence of trade secrets. A party invoking such protection must demonstrate why its confidentiality interests outweigh the interest in criminal prosecution.
A staff manual contains organizational information that may well be relevant for determining whether reporting obligations were breached. This is particularly true where proceedings are directed against unknown individuals because the authorities lack knowledge of the bank’s internal organization.
The Court also rejected the argument that competitors might gain access to sensitive information. An unsealing order does not automatically grant third parties access to the documents. Legitimate confidentiality interests can still be protected at a later stage, for example by restricting third-party access to the case file.
Legal Professional Privilege
Under Article 171 of the Swiss Criminal Procedure Code (CrimPC) and Article 321 of the Swiss Criminal Code (SCC), lawyers registered in the cantonal bar register are subject to legal professional privilege. According to the prevailing view, however, in-house counsel are not holders of professional secrecy in this sense, irrespective of whether they possess a lawyer’s licence.
In reaching this conclusion, the Court relied heavily on the legislative history. A proposed Federal Act on Corporate Counsel presented in 2009 failed during the consultation process. When Article 167a CPC was later enacted, the Federal Council deliberately refrained from amending other procedural statutes. Consequently, there is no legislative gap, but rather qualified silence on the part of the legislature. As a result, there is no room for judicial gap-filling or for an analogous application of Article 167a CPC in criminal proceedings.
Compliance Activities and Legal Privilege: An Important Distinction
The Court emphasized another important limitation. Even independent external lawyers are not protected by legal privilege with respect to all activities they perform. Where they undertake statutory compliance functions, particularly AML compliance obligations for banks, such work constitutes ancillary business activity rather than core legal practice. Accordingly, it does not fall within the scope of professional secrecy.
The Federal Supreme Court left open the question whether the contested documents in the present case related to such compliance activities.
Practical Implications for Companies
For businesses, the judgment has several important consequences:
- Internal legal advice is not protected from seizure in criminal proceedings.
- Sensitive internal investigations and legal reviews should be carefully structured. Where privilege protection is essential, companies should instruct external, registered lawyers to perform activities that fall within the traditional scope of legal practice.
- Parties invoking confidentiality or privilege must substantiate their claims in detail. Before the Federal Supreme Court, it is not sufficient merely to refer to earlier submissions.
The Key Principle
Protection of confidential communications does not arise from a lawyer’s role within a company. It arises only from legally protected activities that are characteristic of the legal profession.
What This Decision Teaches Us
The judgment provides welcome clarity in an area that had remained uncertain since the introduction of Article 167a CPC. The civil-procedure-based in-house privilege is a narrowly defined exception with limited reach. In criminal and administrative criminal proceedings, the stricter traditional regime continues to apply, leaving companies without equivalent protection.
At the same time, the Federal Supreme Court reaffirmed the demanding standards of substantiation in sealing proceedings. Any party seeking to exclude documents from review must provide a concrete and persuasive balancing of interests in its favour. General references to confidentiality are insufficient.
Key Takeaway for Legal Departments
For legal departments, the decision serves as a clear reminder: the same memorandum may be protected in civil proceedings yet be subject to seizure in criminal proceedings. What matters is not how confidential a document was intended to be, but rather the nature of the proceedings in which disclosure is sought and the identity and function of the person who prepared it.
The judgment is therefore more than a mere unsealing decision. It demonstrates that the legislature intentionally drew the line where it currently stands. Those wishing to move that boundary must seek change through the political process, not through the courts.
FAQs
-
Does Article 167a CPC Also Apply in Criminal Proceedings?
No. The right of in-house legal departments to refuse cooperation applies only in civil proceedings. The Swiss Federal Supreme Court has rejected any analogous application in criminal or administrative criminal proceedings.
-
Are In-House Counsel Protected if They Hold a Lawyer's Licence?
Under current law, no. Lawyers registered in the cantonal bar register are clearly protected by legal professional privilege. According to the prevailing view, however, in-house counsel do not qualify as holders of professional secrecy under Article 171 of the Swiss Criminal Procedure Code (CrimPC) and Article 321 of the Swiss Criminal Code (SCC), even if they hold a lawyer's licence.
-
Can Trade Secrets Be Invoked in Sealing Proceedings?
Yes, but only if substantiated in detail. In administrative criminal proceedings, private secrets must be protected pursuant to Article 50(1) of the Federal Act on Administrative Criminal Law (ACL). However, the affected party must specifically demonstrate why its interest in confidentiality outweighs the public interest in criminal prosecution. General or blanket assertions are insufficient.
-
Is Compliance Work Protected by Legal Professional Privilege?
As a rule, no. Statutorily mandated compliance activities, such as those required under the Anti-Money Laundering Act (AMLA), are considered ancillary business activities rather than core legal services. Consequently, they are not covered by legal professional privilege, even when performed by an independent external lawyer.
-
Will Competitors Gain Access to My Confidential Information Through Unsealing?
Not automatically. An unsealing order merely allows the investigating authority to review the documents. Legitimate confidentiality interests can still be protected at a later stage, for example by restricting third-party access to the case file.